Return to Seminole County Watch main homepage

Front Page 
 
  News
  School Board
  County Commission
  Supervisor of Elections
  Other County Offices
  Municipalities
  State
  Nation
 
  Commentary
  School Board
  County Commission
  Supervisor of Elections
  Other County offices
  Municipalities
  State
  Nation
 
  Columns
  Slats Murphy
  A Different View from Darren Glaude
   
  Wistfully Thinking: Valerie Parnell
 
  About Us
 
  Contact us
Search

Columns : Wistfully Thinking: Valerie Parnell Last Updated: Jun 19th, 2005 - 20:05:13


Disingenuous School Board members can use a lesson in civics
 

By Valerie Parnell, Seminole County Watch columnist
May 7, 2005

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Valerie Parnell, Seminole County Watch columnist
Leave it to Beaver, and older brother Wally, to bring things into perspective.

While flipping channels recently, coincidence, or perhaps intended fate, led me to land upon an episode of Leave It to Beaver at exactly the moment when older-brother Wally was offering the following to Beaver:

"We learned about it in civics class.  In a democracy, everyone has to do things for the common good."

Perhaps they still teach that in civics class, or its modern equivalent, in Seminole County schools.  Whether they do or not, it is a lesson the Seminole County School Board needs to take to heart.

School Board members say they do believe it, and that they use the "common good" as the barometer and compass of their actions.  Their actions speak louder than words, however, proving the lie in what they say.

You do not build an elementary school on contaminated toxic land when you are seeking the common good.  You do not ignore clearly stated rules for naming a community's school when you are seeking the common good.  And you do not displace thousands more students than necessary from their community schools when you are seeking the common good.

Even more so, you do not invoke distortion and deceit to put the best public face on hideous actions that are contrary to the common good.  Yet the School Board has not hesitated to do all of this.  Unanimously.  a five to nothing vote, each time.  No dissenters.

It is disingenuous to claim pursuit of the common good while intending to build an elementary school on toxic land, saying there is no other choice, and then to profess relief at being saved from your own cruel and heartless decision when another choice presents itself.

It is disingenuous to claim pursuit of the common good in naming a high school to flatter one retiring school superintendent when the community in which the high school exists desires another name, their desire reflective of the community's true deference to the common good.

It is disingenuous to implement a high school rezoning plan that tears apart a community that has developed over decades of mutual caring among its residents, when an alternative plan would have kept the community intact while meeting high school enrollment demands.

It is "disingenuous" that is the word that comes to mind each time someone mentions the Seminole County School Board, its members and its superintendent.

Wally and the Beav learned it in their school's civics class and carried the lesson home. 

"In a democracy, everyone has to do things for the common good."

How ironic that a television sitcom exudes respect and concern for the underpinnings of our democracy, while the Seminole County School Board reduces it to a bad joke.

Send an email to Valerie Parnell


Seminole County Watch.com



Top of Page

Wistfully Thinking: Valerie Parnell
Latest Headlines
Freshman commissioners illustrate best and worst of behavior
Just like a decade ago, commissioners lack courage to take necessary action
Bandwagon rolling through Seminole may not be taking proper path
Where the line is drawn should not depend upon personal motivation
School District again relents after stirring up hornets' nest of unnecessary controversy
Disingenuous School Board members can use a lesson in civics
Light up, Oviedo: City Council's decision even worse than originally thought
The smoking gun: Oviedo City Council changes ordinance to allow cigar bar
When I'm gone will be too late to do all that must be done
The folly of government: making sport of what they do